As a result of being made to feel ‘Other,’ we get a very specific message, don’t we? When we’re the one who was made to feel different, for whatever that reason was, whatever that difference was…we learn somehow that we are ‘less than,’ less deserving. But that doesn’t have to continue defining us. We can make a different choice, a choice to act from a place of courage and clarity.”
Ariana Miyamoto will be representing Japan in the Miss Universe pageant. Tall and strikingly beautiful in that way that women who win national beauty pageant tend to be, Ariana nonetheless has a story of Otherness. The child of a Japanese mother and an African-American father, Ariana was bullied by other children in Nagasaki where she grew up. They even threw garbage at her. And her story is like that of biracial children all over the world.
Children of mixed descent have historically struggled to find acceptance in the racially-divided worlds in which most grow up. Some physically resemble one racial group more than the other, while others are visibly of mixed descent. Finding a racial and cultural place to call “home” presents as a real challenge for many.
Ariana grew up in Japan, a nation in which 98.5% of the population are Japanese, with small pockets of people from other Asian countries and an additional .06% specifically identified as “other” by the U.S. Central Intelligence Agency. Standing head and shoulders above the rest and with the darker skin of her father’s heritage, Ariana was visibly different from the people around her. This was the basis of their mistreatment of her. She knew all along that she was Other.
Importantly, she didn’t let that stop her. She’s still not stopping, even as people criticize the notion of a woman who is not fully Japanese representing the nation in the Miss Universe pageant. She’s said that this inspires her to push even harder. My favorite part is that she is using her Otherness as its own source of inspiration. She has a gift in that she is different, and she’s giving herself permission to use that gift.
Her story is a poignant one because it’s tells a of journey of the kid who felt the pain that so many biracial children and adults can claim for their own. More broadly, hers is the story of all of us. She was the kid who was different. She was Other, and she still is. No doubt on those days when someone called her a name and threw garbage at her, she cried, askedherself “Why?”, and struggled to hold her head up the next day. Today though, she’s not letting her Otherness hold her back. She’s carrying herself forward. She’s never stopped.
I hope she does extremely well in Miss Universe and beyond, in whatever she wishes to pursue in her life. Go, Ariana!
Bruce Jenner is one of us. Most specifically, I speak of her as a transgender woman whom I now call my sister. She needs us as much as we need her; and her story, while told in a very different setting than reflects most people’s reality, is the story of all transgender women.
To be sure, there are many aspects of Her life that are completely foreign to anyone except, well, Her. (“Her” is how she referred to the female identity that’s always been present. I use this instead of “Bruce” because I am constitutionally unable to call a transgender woman by her birth-assigned male name).
Yet, as I listened to her interview with Diane Sawyer, which I found to be respectful and appropriately educating (you could have dropped the male pronouns once she came out though, Diane), I heard a story I’ve heard many, many times. I’ve even told it of myself. As children living in an experience as the Gender Other, we have clear definition or understanding to describe what is in our hearts and minds. We know that we feel somehow wrong in our gender role. Some of us are smart enough to figure out that we’re more identified as girls than boys, or boys than girls, as the case may be. Yet, there is a sense of being so distant from others of our sex that we are often going through motions that are based on what someone else expects us to do without any understanding of why. Many of us become young actors before we can even complete elementary school.
As time goes on, our development continues along its own path. Many of us are unable to mask our gender expression, and our behaviors fall outside of what people consider gender appropriate. For feminine boys, this, in a word, is hell. Often ridiculed, humiliated, and physically abused; we run, duck, and stumble our way through school until we can reach the relative safety of adult lives and the ability to choose freely for ourselves. Many of us never make it this far, as the high incidence of transgender teen suicide attests. Many who do live on to experience the struggle of existence in a world that offers few safe harbors for transgender women. We do what we must, and it’s not always pretty.
She was not bullied in school. She didn’t need to engage in sex work or deal drugs to survive in a world that would otherwise give her nothing. She was never fired from a job or even passed over for a promotion. Instead, she was an elite athlete in school, and later, an Olympic decathlon winner. She married beautiful women, raised beautiful children, and presented to the world our culture’s ideal of manhood.
Her torment, though, was always there.
This is why she needs us most. Whereas we who have lived through transphobia quickly learn the value of community and resiliency that comes with it, she will be impeded to reach us. Whereas other Los Angeles area transwomen can anonymously slip into an area support group or have a girls night out in West Hollywood, ease of community access will not be Her own. She will be relentlessly followed by paparazzi wherever she goes for the foreseeable future. Her every move in her transition will be documented for the world.
Far from the scripted reality people consume from television, she is a transgender woman moving through an intensely personal, confusing struggle. No one understands this better than we. And no one can tell her that it really is going to be okay as we can, because we know that at the end of the day, the courage it takes to be transgender is itself a guiding purpose. We can tell her that being transgender is in fact a blessing, an opportunity, a source of joy in that we have a life that we created without any blueprint. Many of us suffer from depression; and yet, the bigger story is in our triumph, in our ability to rise each day and make a decision to live in our truth.
What’s more, the transgender community needs Her. Until the Diane Sawyer interview, there was no major television broadcast that educated so many millions of viewers on transgender identity. We transgender folks knew the story well, but very few people outside the community did. Now they do. Now, when they see us, they see her. They know something of our struggle. And that opens them to more questions. People who ask questions instead of foreclosing with an answer they’ve already made based on prejudice are those who can serve as our allies in the struggle for justice. And that is a very good thing.
Sister did her part. Are we who watched her story, admiring her courage, ready to ours?